Compass Island Jupiter Waterfront Homes for Sale

by Babu

Compass Island Jupiter Waterfront Homes for Sale | Luxury Real Estate

What’s It Like Living in Compass Island?

Imagine waking up to the gentle flow of the Wild and Scenic Loxahatchee River, your private dock just steps from your lanai, and your boat ready for a quick cruise out to the Intracoastal Waterway and Atlantic Ocean. That’s everyday life at Compass Island in Jupiter, Florida.

This boutique enclave is comprised of only 23 custom estates, built between 1997 and 2000. Each home is unique, yet all share a refined elegance — marble or tile flooring, soaring volume ceilings, gourmet kitchens, covered lanais, summer kitchens, and sparkling private pools. Many also include boat lifts and private docks, giving residents a true boater’s lifestyle.

The neighborhood vibe here is tranquil and intimate. Unlike sprawling master-planned communities, Compass Island feels like a private retreat — one where neighbors know each other, children ride bikes safely, and families gather around the water. All this, yet you’re just minutes from Jupiter’s lively dining, shopping, and beaches.

Real Estate Market Trends

The Compass Island market is defined by exclusivity and limited inventory. With only 23 estates, opportunities to buy are rare. In the past six months:

One current listing on Compass Island is priced at $3.35M, or $1,117/sq. ft.
A recent sale closed at $2.5M, or about $975/sq. ft.
In contrast, the broader Jupiter median home price is $660,000, down 4.3% year-over-year.

While Jupiter’s overall market leans toward a buyer’s market with longer days on market (90 days average), Compass Island’s exclusivity means homes retain strong value. This community caters to high-end buyers who prioritize boating access, privacy, and luxury finishes.

Simon’s Insight: “Compass Island is where the rarity of supply meets high demand. Even in a shifting market, these estates remain highly desirable. When one becomes available, you need to move fast — but strategically.”

Local Flavor: Top 3 Restaurants

U-Tiki Beach

Simon’s Take: “I love the relaxed island vibe here — perfect for unwinding after a day on the water.”

Guanabanas

Simon’s Insight: “It’s one of my go-to spots for weekend nights — the ambiance and local feel are unmatched.”

Jupiter Grill

Simon’s Perspective: “Perfect for special occasions — the service here is impeccable, and the atmosphere truly special.”

Outdoor Lifestyle: Top 3 Parks

DuBois Park

Simon’s Take: “A perfect mix of history and water fun—ideal for families exploring local heritage and sun-soaked strolls.”

Carlin Park

Simon’s Take: “Whether it’s a morning jog or a family picnic by the water—Carlin Park delivers every time.”

Riverbend Park

Simon’s Take: “When it’s time to unplug and reconnect with the wild side of Jupiter — this is it.”

Local Shops & Boutiques

The Shops of Harbour Place

Simon’s Insight: “The waterfront setting with boutique shops and great food makes it a perfect Jupiter lifestyle spot.”

Blueline Surf & Paddle Co.

Simon’s Insight: “Blueline captures Jupiter’s laid-back coastal vibe — it’s more than shopping, it’s a lifestyle.”

The Love Street Project

Simon’s Insight: “I picked up a coastal-inspired gift here last holiday. It’s a go-to when you want something personal and very ‘Jupiter.’”

Schools & Family Appeal

Families in Compass Island are zoned for top-rated Martin County schools:

Hobe Sound Elementary – nurturing early learning, community feel.
Murray Middle School – strong academics, STEM & arts programs.
South Fork High School – IB diploma, AP courses, 26 varsity sports.

Nearby private options include The Pine School, Jupiter Christian, and Turtle River Montessori.

Simon’s Take: “One of the best parts about Compass Island is the access to high-quality schools. Families feel confident investing here knowing education is top-tier.”

Is Compass Island a Good Investment?

Absolutely. Here’s why:

Exclusivity: Just 23 estates — scarcity drives long-term value.
Boating lifestyle: Few places offer direct Intracoastal & ocean access like this.
Luxury homes: 3,000–6,000 sq. ft., with high-end finishes.
Tax-friendly Martin County: Lower property taxes than neighboring Palm Beach County.
Resale strength: Even in a softening market, Compass Island homes remain in demand.

Simon’s Insight: “Compass Island is one of those rare communities where lifestyle and investment meet. These homes aren’t just residences — they’re legacies.”